Annie  Caruso

Annie Caruso

Get to Know Me

As a multi‑million‑dollar REALTOR® with Circle Real Estate, Annie Caruso delivers a refined, client‑centered experience for buyers and sellers across Indianapolis and its surrounding suburbs. Known for her thoughtful communication, strategic insight, and elevated service, Annie guides clients through both traditional and high‑end real estate with clarity, confidence, and exceptional care.
 
Clients frequently highlight Annie’s calm presence and clear communication as hallmarks of her service. She believes that informed clients are empowered clients, and she takes the time to explain each step, demystify the process, and ensure her clients always understand their options. From the first conversation through closing—and beyond—Annie’s goal is simple: to make the real estate experience as seamless, rewarding, and memorable as possible.
 
Her leadership in the industry includes serving as the 2024 MIBOR Realtor Association Board President and 2025 Immediate Past President, reflecting her commitment to professionalism, advocacy, and strengthening the Central Indiana real estate community. Annie is also deeply engaged in local volunteer efforts, supporting organizations and initiatives that enrich the neighborhoods she serves.  
 
Outside of work and volunteerism, Annie enjoys walks through her neighborhood with Sir Henry James, her spirited 5½‑year‑old dog, and quiet evenings unwinding with cozy snuggles from Ruby, her beloved 13‑year‑old cat. Together, they remind her daily of the comfort, warmth, and character that make a house truly feel like home.  
 
Whether you are embarking on your first home purchase, considering a sale of a property, or exploring new beginnings, Annie Caruso offers dedicated expertise, trusted guidance, and a collaborative partnership tailored to your unique journey.
Buyer
Amber S.
Carmel
WHAT MY CLIENTS SAY

Annie did an amazing job of guiding us through the process of purchasing our first home. She really listened to what we needed and helped us find the perfect house. Specific reasons I would recommend Annie would be her attention to detail, construction knowledge (especially helpful when looking at older homes that may need some work), and responsiveness. The main reason I would recommend Annie would be t...

— Buyer

WHAT MY CLIENTS SAY

Annie just helped my fiance and I in buying our first home. She was so wonderful in helping us truly understand the whole process. She always made time to meet with us or talk over the telephone whenever we had questions or concerns. She was always honest in giving us her opinion on properties. Most importantly to me, she really cares about her clients. She personally checked in with me several times whe...

— Amber S.

WHAT MY CLIENTS SAY

Annie showed tremendous knowledge of the area in which I was interested in purchasing a home. She was not afraid to give honest feedback on whether the property was a risky venture due to unattended repair needs or was priced above market value. She also never shied away from recommending a property she thought met my criteria even though I may have overlooked it.

— Buyer

WHAT MY CLIENTS SAY

I have worked with Annie over the past few years in my search for rental properties. I have found her to be very knowledgeable about the home buying process as well as the specific parts of town I was looking in. She is always very responsive and quick to return a call. I highly recommend Annie.

— Buyer | Seller

How much is your Indy Area home worth?

  • Instant property valuation
  • Expert advice
  • Sell for more

Portfolio

For Sale
For Lease
Sold

Find Your Dream Home

Browse Homes

Work with Annie

I believe that satisfying the customer is simply the minimum requirement for staying in business. I work constantly to improve our systems, processes, and services to go well beyond the standard level of service provided by most agents.